It is known as the teaching package Association, and the tuition fee is refundable by 0 yuan or installment payment Can you really win and make a lot of money after online dubbing training? "Good afternoon, classmate. You can take a look at the student of the teacher. Because the salary is not high, you want to develop a sideline and increase your income. After work, you can use your spare time to receive the dubbing list to obtain income. There is an additional income of 3000 + a week." "You can take a look at our student. He received some wedding videos and recordings during the Spring Festival, and his income is very considerable. Today is the last day of the countdown to the event. Give yourself a chance to learn and change. Sign up for the lucky draw: iphone13, free tickets, cash red envelopes, headphones, and add teachers and friends to consult about the year of the tiger." …… In recent years, with the rise of audio books and short videos, recording audio books and dubbing have also attracted public attention. Some training institutions see the business opportunities and vigorously carry out relevant training. However, some of these training institutions are profit-making and have behaviors such as excessive marketing, false publicity and inducing consumption, which seriously infringe on the legitimate rights and interests of consumers. In the first half of last year, the State Administration of market supervision and administration inspected this phenomenon, and many well-known training institutions were punished for false publicity, fictitious original prices and false preferential discounts. What are the "pitfalls" of such training institutions? How to regulate? With these problems, the reporter of the rule of law Daily recently conducted an in-depth investigation. Known as 100% employment Change your face after paying the tuition "From 7 o'clock to 9 o'clock tonight, Miss Lu is specially invited to give lectures. She is a TV host and a provincial Putonghua tester. She graduated from the broadcasting Department of Communication University of China, studied in the dubbing class of the performance Department of Beijing Film Academy, and won the most popular award in the sound excellence competition of China International Animation Festival..." On January 26 this year, the reporter experienced a free high-quality course of audio book dubbing in an educational institution online. Before class, the teaching assistant sent the information of the lecturer and the lecture link, and stressed that this is an exclusive link, which was missed and not replayed. In fact, after the reporter forwards the "exclusive link", others can log in and watch it normally. At the beginning of the course, Mr. Lu didn't introduce professional knowledge, Instead, it describes the bright prospects of the dubbing industry: "audio books, short videos, wedding hosting, etc. there is a huge gap of employees in this industry. As long as we can receive orders, we can earn money. We cooperate with more than 180 part-time sideline order receiving platforms, and we can achieve 100% employment by choosing our courses." After that, Mr. Lu skillfully changed various tones and voice lines to show the dubbing for the students. After talking about the little skills of how to sound for more than ten minutes, he began to show the case of successful students - "this classmate received orders at home during the holiday, earning more than 5000 yuan in half a month, and she couldn't get the orders", "this schoolgirl used her spare time to study and receive orders, and now her monthly income is more than 10000 yuan..." At the end of the course, Mr. Lu reminded that only by signing up now can we enjoy the exclusive price of Mr. Lu's employment class, and give away excellent courses worth 7320 yuan; The original price of the studio class is 7660 yuan, the exclusive price is 4580 yuan, the original price of the advanced class is 8160 yuan, the exclusive price is 4980 yuan, the original price of the all-round class is 10840 yuan, and the exclusive price is 5580 yuan. You can learn in three months. Only the top 15 people who contact customer service. More than 50 minutes of the 90 minute live class are using various "scripts" to attract students to buy the course. Moreover, the reporters as like as two peas in the 3 different training institutions, showed that the content and process of the course were almost identical except for the different PPT pictures. On the relevant complaint platform, the reporter saw that many consumers complained that after spending a high training fee, many live classes on the original schedule were reduced to video classes. In a few live classes, students were unable to interact with teachers, and the promised one-on-one teaching was not achieved. The teacher will only leave some tongue twisters and Putonghua pronunciation training after class, and the feedback on the training of students is very lagging, "my attitude towards me is different before and after paying the tuition". The reporter's investigation found that the teachers of some training institutions are suspected of "over packaging". The institutions publicize that these teachers are "CCTV dubbing engineers", but in fact, they only dub several advertisements on an app; Some teachers were advertised as having won the most popular award in a sound contest, but the reporter searched the list of winners and found no one. Insiders told reporters that many "gold medal teachers" of training institutions are actually just college students majoring in broadcasting and hosting. The contents taught in the class are basically on the teaching materials of broadcasting, so there will be a situation that the course contents of many training institutions are completely consistent. It is not only the problem of teachers and teaching, but also the problem of false publicity in tuition fees. In online advertisements, you can often see the publicity of 0 yuan, 1 yuan and zero basic dubbing. The reporter randomly opened one of the advertising links. After filling in the personal information, a teacher added the reporter's social account and learned the materials. The reporter opened and found that it was a 45 minute audition class. The staff of the institution told reporters that it takes three to six months to complete all courses, and the tuition fee ranges from 7000 yuan to 10000 yuan. "Didn't the advertisement say that you can learn for 0 yuan?" The reporter asked. The other party replied: the admission of 0 yuan is not free, but the installment loan service can be provided here. The tuition can be paid in installments for up to 18 months. "The admission of 0 yuan is to go through the installment loan, and then pay back hundreds of yuan of tuition every month". Recommend students to use online loan Claim unconditional refund "There is a discount of about 9000 yuan for each class. There is only a discount of about 3000 yuan for each class." Unable to withstand the teacher's recommendation, Xiaolin from Chengdu, Sichuan added the other party's contact information. After hearing that he could pay in installments and received the guarantee that "if he is not satisfied, he can refund unconditionally within 14 days without commission and interest", Xiaolin applied for a loan to pay the tuition. After listening to the three-day course, Kobayashi was very dissatisfied with the course content and arrangement, so he contacted the other party to apply for a refund, but the other party kept pushing back, and repeatedly persuaded him that it would be good to finish the course, which would be helpful for his future. Kobayashi found the customer service of the lender's platform for consultation and learned that the refund can only be applied for by the training institution. Kobayashi went to the training institution again, and the other party replied that the trainees can only apply for three refunds. Now they have failed three times, and the money cannot be refunded. At present, Kobayashi can only protect his rights while repaying more than 500 yuan of installment loans every month. In the investigation, the reporter found that in order to make people more "confident" to enter the school, many training institutions will take the initiative to mention "education loans", and claim that such loans have no interest and handling charges, and can be unconditionally refunded within a certain time limit or at any time. The reporter clicked on the loan application link sent by one of the customer service and found that although the interest in the loan agreement is not high, it is not interest free, and a certain proportion of handling fee needs to be paid. After seeing the reporter's unpaid payment, the other party said that the preferential link had only a two-hour period and expired. Two days later, the customer service sent a screenshot saying that the last application had been invalidated. If you want to learn about loans, you can continue to apply. It is worth noting that when some training institutions help students apply for loans, the reporter will remind them that they should choose enterprise personnel for occupation, fill in college or undergraduate education, and fill in more than 10000 yuan for monthly salary, so that the loan is fast and the amount is high. It is understood that some minors have also taken online loans. In addition, a number of students told reporters that after insisting on learning, the training institutions did not introduce job opportunities and part-time channels as promised at the beginning, but quickly dissolved the student group. The novice part-time order receiving websites strongly recommended by some training institutions often require students to pay fees for many times before they have the opportunity to test and receive orders. Even if they receive orders, the income is very small, which is far lower than the cost promised by the training institutions. The reporter learned from the investigation that in order to achieve the publicity effect of training institutions, it is necessary to enter the larger audio production platforms in the market, and these platforms often have a strict audit mechanism: professional equipment recording is required, and mobile phone recording is not accepted; Graduated from broadcasting, hosting, dubbing and other related majors, or more than 1 year of broadcasting and commercial distribution experience; Simple post production ability, basic editing, etc. People in the dubbing industry told reporters that although there are more and more dubbing work on the network, it is not without threshold. Most of the real sound practitioners are professional professionals with a good sound foundation and accumulated training for a long time, while the income of most dubbing actors is not high. The so-called 1000 yuan per hour of some dubbing training institutions can easily earn more than 10000 yuan a month by taking a part-time job, which is simply unrealistic. According to insiders, the package orders publicized by some institutions are actually to package themselves as Party A, find some cheap copyright books, and buy students' time to record books at a lower price. 10 hours of dry sound is not much money, and the class fees paid by students in front can fully cover this cost. There are many violations of laws and regulations Training institutions need regulation According to the experts interviewed by the reporter, these training institutions have a variety of violations. Zhu Xiaojuan, associate professor of the school of civil and commercial economics and law of China University of political science and law, believes that voice training belongs to professional training. Training institutions should first obtain the relevant qualifications and the permission of the education department, and carry out training according to the basic conditions required for training. Accordingly, teachers should also meet the requirements of teacher qualifications and academic qualifications, so as to ensure the purpose of professional training, Many training institutions and their teachers obviously do not meet this requirement. Tang Yu, a lawyer at Beijing Yinghe law firm, told reporters that according to the relevant provisions of China's advertising law, advertising content should not contain false or misleading content, and should not deceive or mislead consumers, Similar to "receive zero yuan within a limited time", "guide price of 99 yuan, buy class hours and send sound cards", if the relevant class hours do not trade at the advertised price, it is suspected of price fraud. "Advertisements for education and training shall not contain any explicit or implied guarantee commitment to the effect of education and training, nor shall they contain any recommendation or proof in the name or image of scientific research institutions, academic institutions, educational institutions, industry associations, professionals and beneficiaries. From these Provisions, these training and education institutions do not meet the requirements." Tang Yu said. Tang Yu said: "Online signing brings a lot of inconvenience to the settlement of disputes and disputes in the later stage. Students advocate cancelling and cancelling the training contract and asking for a refund. They often communicate with customer service over and over the phone, but many training institutions can't reply and deal with students' complaints in time. In addition, some students consider maintaining the training contract through legal channels such as litigation and arbitration The cost of legitimate rights and interests is too high. It can't be settled after negotiation, which also reduces the illegal cost of some training institutions. " According to the reporter's investigation, some training institutions publish drainage advertisements on the online platform, manage students in the social group, and set up live broadcasting